The voices of Tax Policy Center's researchers and staff
Americans agonize each spring over their annual federal income tax returns. In terms of how much tax they pay, however, they should worry more about the payroll taxes their employers withhold from every paycheck. After all, three-quarters of those who pay one or both taxes shell out more for payroll taxes than for income tax.
The Tax Policy Center estimates that 44 percent of households will pay no federal income tax this year (down from the 47 percent famously cited by Mitt Romney in 2012). But 60 percent of those households have members who work and will thus pay Social Security and Medicare payroll taxes. As the light blue block shows, that’s about one-quarter of all households.
Nearly half of all households will pay both income and payroll taxes (the dark yellow and dark blue blocks). Almost three-fourths of them will pay more in payroll taxes than in income taxes. Just 7 percent of households (the light yellow block) will owe income tax but no payroll tax because they don’t have any wage income.
Source: Tax Policy Center, Distribution of Federal Payroll and Income Taxes by Expanded Cash Income Percentile, 2016
Overall, almost two-thirds of households will pay more payroll tax than income tax (the two blue blocks), while only one in five will pay more income tax (the two yellow blocks).
And what about the remaining 18 percent who pay neither tax? More than half are retirees living on Social Security and too little other income to owe income tax. The rest have no jobs and not much income. That isn’t a club many would want to join.
Posts and comments are solely the opinion of the author and not that of the Tax Policy Center, Urban Institute, or Brookings Institution.
In this July 26, 2012, photo, Neta Homier looks over bills in her home in Toledo, Ohio. Homier says she relies on Social Security to pay her bills and while she is confident the program will continue to help her she fears it will not be able to rely on it. "Social Security is what’s carrying me," Homier said. "It pays all my bills." People retiring today are part of the first generation of workers who have paid more in Social Security taxes during their careers than they will receive in benefits after they retire. It’s a historic shift that will only get worse for future retirees, according to an analysis by The Associated Press. Previous generations got a much better bargain, mainly because payroll taxes were very low when Social Security was enacted in the 1930s and remained so for decades. (AP Photo/Carlos Osorio)